Did Facebook Just Kill Social Media Management? - Social Media Explorer
Did Facebook Just Kill Social Media Management?
Did Facebook Just Kill Social Media Management?

The death of social media management, that’s a bold statement to make, and one not to be taken out of context. For those social media practitioners among you are who actively managing a Facebook page, you may well already be aware of the changes that Facebook just rolled out to its Edgerank algorithm. It seems this update has slipped under the radar for many, which could be due to the fact that the platform it was distributed through, the relatively new Facebook For Business, may still be unfamiliar to many in the industry. Before we descend into anarchy and panic however, it’s necessary to define our key terms and figure out exactly what this new update means and what it foretells.

What Is Social Media Management?

There are countless definitions of what social media management actually entails. I value simplicity, so I define social media management as: “The act of growing, developing and monitoring a social media platform to meet any number of business, or personal, objectives”. Simply put this can mean anything from the intern you hired to update your Facebook page, to a full team of managers, designers and developers running campaigns across multiple platforms.

At this point I think it’s fair to say that most people have an inkling of what social media management entails, what they don’t have however, is a thorough understanding of what it should entail and how to differentiate between Black Hat Social Media Management and White Hat Social Media Management. This is where things get tricky and where the new Edgerank updates are going to hit hard.

Black Hat Social Media Management? Isn’t Black Hat An SEO Term?

‘Black Hat’ is a term that we have begun using interchangeably to describe unethical, or ineffective, methodology in the online marketing world, it’s no longer just a term to be used by an SEO Company. There have been debates raging for years now about what effective social media actually entails, what are your vanity metrics, how do we measure and present a real ROI in terms of leads, sales, repeat purchases and so on.

URL BuilderThankfully, over the past couple of years there have been some big leaps in terms of connecting the dots and plugging social into the bigger picture. I’m talking about advancements in Facebook’s own insights and measurement capability, as well as the ability to effectively plug in social referrals to Google Analytics, using Google’s URL Builder and more recently Google’s further focus on social signals and the introduction of ‘Contributed Social Conversions’ and ‘Last Interaction Social Conversions’. These last two metrics can be found under traffic sources in your social overview.

But back on point, what does ‘Black Hat Social Media Management’ actually entail?

The Black Hat Checklist

As Facebook succinctly describes unethical social practices; black hat social media is designed to ‘game’ the system. Black hat social media entails:

  • The posting will consist primarily of low quality content that delivers little to no value to its audience, i.e memes, poorly constructed posts and content that does not resonate with its proposed audience.
  • The posting will focus primarily on calls to action and ‘forcing’ an engagement from its audience, i.e “Make sure you like this picture”.
  • There is little to no original content being produced, rather the focus is purely on syndication of others content.
  • When content is shared, it’s shared from untrustworthy sources or communities with ‘low quality’ followings when taken into context with the sharer’s own audience.
  • The primary objective of the posting will be to elicit ‘likes’, ‘shares’ or engagement at any cost, effectively chasing vanity metrics. This results in a poor experience for the user and a disconnect between organic page fans and the page itself.

Facebook, it seems, is effectively moving in the same direction as Google. These initial changes have been introduced to crack down on social media practitioners ‘gaming’ the system. As with Google, simply blasting a website with thousands of links is in no way a good indicator of context, or value, to the producer of a search query.

The typical example here with Facebook, is the page that is built primarily on ‘likes’ which hold no value to the page, or page owner, itself. It has become regular practice for many black hat social media practitioners to ‘share’ memes and other posts in groups, or online communities, with a large number of fans in order to generate engagement for their clients. As a result, these pages are being built on false hope and pure vanity.

How To Measure Social MediaFor example, a local coffee shop in Boulder, Colorado, has no need of thousands of fans from Portugal, Spain, or Europe, unless they plan on exporting their coffee there in the very near future! Page size and engagement when taken secularly offer no value whatsoever, to the community or the page owner. These metrics need to be looked at with scrutiny and integrated into the bigger picture so to speak. A good place to start if you are looking to offer real measurements to a client is Nichole Kelly’s book on How To Measure Social Media.

The White Hat Checklist

Now that we’ve covered what’s considered black hat, let’s run through what we consider to be white hat social media management:

  • The underlying objective of any social media campaign is to deliver value to its audience. Value to be defined as any content that will educate, inspire, or enrich the participants Facebook experience on a particular page.
  • Posts will not attempt to game the system, or the end user, into taking action purely to generate an increase in engagement or activity.
  • The focus will be on creating original, unique and valuable content for the fan base.

Running a white hat campaign is simple, and these principles will be familiar to any veteran social media marketer out there.

The Changes

After defining our key terms and putting the recent Edgerank developments in context, I’ll now present my take on the recent changes:

  • Is this timely and relevant content? The key word here is relevancy. As with Google’s continuing quest for relevancy and context, it seems Facebook is now placing a heavier emphasis on relevancy when developing its own algorithm.
  • Is the content genuinely interesting to you, or is it trying to game News Feed Distribution? This is by far the most important development, in my opinion. This update is focused on quality of content and a heavy crackdown on vanity metrics. While it might seem great for a small business page to post a funny meme and have this shared in multiple countries and regions, it’s generating no affinity with its real fan base and thus ultimately hurting the pages ability to generate any real value to the owner.
  • Is this content from a source you would trust? Vanity metrics might seem great to the uninitiated executive. They get to take a great progress report to their CEO, hundreds of thousands and likes and impressions, everybody wins, right? Wrong. When using the above black hat methods to generate engagement and results your pages Trust Rating is going to drop dramatically. Not only that, but any fan of substance, what I call an ‘organic fan’ (someone who is genuinely a viable prospect for you) is going to begin to disconnect with your page over time because they aren’t receiving any real value, and by now most people are aware of when they are being gamed by ‘forced engagements’ in the news feed.

You can review the full summary of the Edgerank updates here.

What’s Next?

As with any batch of algorithmic changes, the impact will be small to begin with, then all of a sudden the social hammer will drop and thousands of black hat practitioners will be out of a job when even their black hat practices fail to generate any kind of result for their clients. Ultimately however, these changes are a good move in the right direction and should mean nothing but good things for all of the small businesses, agencies and practitioners out there who are working their butts off putting in hundreds and hundreds of hours to deliver engaging and informative social media campaigns to their audiences.

About the Author

James Thomas
James is a digital growth consultant at Square Internet. Square Internet help small businesses attract, convert, close and delight more customers.
  • Thank you. I learned a lot thanks to your post. I will continue to follow you.

  • Pingback: CreativeAgencySecrets()

  • Amy

    A very insightful article. This is practice of “detoxing” should be a habit for everyone, regardless of age. Now that children are born into a world where phone obsessions are the norm, they need to learn that a balance between the outside world and the internet is healthy. How sad would it be if the value of interactions was decreased to a mere nothing, and people were judged off of their response time to certain issues.

  • Dangerous Donna

    wow, thank you for the insight. I just completed playing “getting sucked into the black hat hole.” Left me high and dry. Keep on with your guidance to us. greatly appreciated

  • Krystel

    Excellent article! Feel free to check this Social Media Blog post about “Contentholism” or social media abuse. Kind regards!

  • Pingback: Social Media Leseempfehlungen | Marketing in Communitys und Social Networks()

  • Jake Parent

    Hopefully we can take 1 step back to go 2 steps forward.

    One of the sad parts about all our online “connectedness” is it seems like we have never really been farther apart.

    More than anything we have to rekindle our relationship building skills. There are plenty of ways the Internet will play a major role in this of course. But, ultimately, if we really want to build communities that harness our shared power to innovate, we have to learn how to REALLY connect with each other.

    To me, that means looking at our online relationships less in the sense that everyone else out in cyberspace is some kind of static audience and instead treat them like they are a dynamic community. In other words, there has to be a sense of shared purpose and a mutual value.

    Thanks for the thoughtful insights.


  • Pingback: dostana()

  • Emily Hunter

    I’ve been pretty unconnected – I only check my email and other messages on he laptop. I don’t have the smartphone or other ways to check my email. What chafes me a lot is when people say, ‘did you see my latest Facebook status?’ when there’s the opportunity to talk about what’s going on right now. So, yes. it’s time for a digital detox for everyone and a move to enjoy the present moment. Thank you for the reminder. :)

  • Funny thing, being overloaded with digital information. I recall that it was not long ago when I was a kid and wished that I had access to the internet all the time. And BOOM, fast forward to today and I have this smartphone device that allows me to be connected to the internet ALL THE TIME. Sometimes I forget how cool this all is.

    Now, amazingly, we have the opposite problem of being too connected. I hate it when the people I’m having dinner with are on their phones all the time. But, I’m guilty of that too. I hate it that having a phone with me allows me to take the easy road and stare at my phone instead of interacting with people around it. But I do that all the time too.

    What’s the solution though? I think you hit the nail on the head. It’s about balance and your personal choices. We’ve got to learn how to deal with this deluge of digital information and decide what are the important things in life to focus on. We have to remember that technology is just a tool, and we have the power to use it in any way you want.

    I love it that you’ve decided to online get back online after your daughter goes to sleep. That’s sounds like great advice for all fathers out there. Thanks for the post Audie!

  • JellyfishAgency

    It is interesting that writing such a piece comes from a professional that is at the cold face of digital marketing where the mantra is to be hard wired all the time. I feel your concerns.

    In some respects, digital agencies need to be aware of live campaign activity, for instance PPC, but in saying that these platforms have alerts and control mechanisms to prevent meltdown in changing circumstances. Social Media is tricky one because it is a channel that needs to be monitored, but again even with the best of intentions it can follow its own path and direction that is beyond the control of governments let alone brands.

    But totally in agreement in relation to a person’s personal branding. It is more about keeping up digital appearances and forgetting about the real elements of personal interaction. Everyone ultimately wants to connect on a personal level not on a digital level. If your Klout score is more important to you than your personal interaction skills then i think you need to step back and go offline for awhile in order to get that human element back.

    Businesses are built on real human relationships.

    • You nailed it! “…It is more about keeping up digital appearances and forgetting about the real elements of personal interaction” AND “Businesses are built on real human relationships.”

  • Pingback: How To Deal With Disruptive Technology As A Small Business | Trustworkz()

  • Pingback: Was Sie verpasst haben: Social-Media-Rückblick KW39 | SMO14 - New Media Excellence()

  • Pingback: Facebook y su definición de Black Hat | Ornitorrinco Digital()

  • Pingback: Did Facebook Just Kill Social Media Management? | fresh fresher peppermint!()

  • Pingback: Pets Take Over Social Media And More In Today's Social Media NewsSocial Media Marketing Reporter()

  • Wilfried Schock

    well done.


Social Media Jobs

VIP Explorer’s Club